When Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez called for prison abolition during a 2019 campaign event, it sent ripples through law enforcement communities nationwide. For officers already feeling the strain of public scrutiny, statements from high-profile politicians advocating for the dismantling of correctional systems can feel like a direct challenge to their profession’s legitimacy and purpose. At Badge145, we understand how political rhetoric impacts the mental well-being of those serving in law enforcement, and we believe in addressing these challenges head-on.
The prison abolition movement isn’t simply about closing facilities—it represents a complex ideology that questions the fundamental principles of our current criminal justice system. Proponents argue for alternatives to incarceration, including restorative justice practices, community-based rehabilitation programs, and addressing root causes of crime through social services.
For law enforcement officers dedicated to public safety, these discussions can feel personal. Many officers see their role as essential to maintaining order and protecting communities from genuine threats. When political figures advocate for abolition without acknowledging the complexity of criminal justice, it can leave officers feeling devalued and misunderstood.
As mental health professionals supporting first responders, we’ve found that creating spaces for honest dialogue about these challenging topics is crucial for officer wellness. These conversations provide opportunities to process complex emotions while developing resilience in a changing social landscape.
Research shows that external criticism and perceived lack of public support significantly impact officer mental health. A 2017 study published in the Journal of Criminal Justice found that officers who perceived higher levels of public criticism reported increased stress, anxiety, and symptoms of depression.
“When I hear politicians calling for abolishing the systems I’ve dedicated my career to upholding, it’s hard not to take it personally,” shares Officer Michael Thompson, a 15-year veteran. “I joined this profession to help people and make my community safer.”
This sentiment resonates with many in law enforcement. The emotional toll of feeling villainized can contribute to burnout, decreased job satisfaction, and even trauma responses in some officers. At Badge145, we emphasize that acknowledging these feelings is not a sign of weakness but the first step toward building resilience.
While political rhetoric can be challenging, there are productive ways for officers to navigate these conversations:
Separate policy criticism from personal value: Remember that critiques of systems don’t negate the positive impact you have in your community.
Engage with diverse perspectives: Understanding various viewpoints doesn’t require agreement but can provide valuable context.
Focus on your direct impact: Regardless of broader political debates, your daily actions to protect and serve matter.
Utilize peer support resources: Connect with fellow officers through peer support groups to process reactions in a safe environment.
Consider your unique role as bridge-builder: Law enforcement officers often have unique insights that can contribute meaningfully to reform discussions.
The essential role of peer support cannot be overstated in helping officers process reactions to political rhetoric. Having colleagues who understand the unique challenges of law enforcement provides validation and perspective that outside support sometimes cannot.
Despite seemingly opposing viewpoints, most prison reform advocates share common goals with law enforcement: creating safer communities, reducing recidivism, and addressing underlying causes of crime. By focusing on these shared objectives, constructive dialogue becomes possible.
“I’ve found that when I listen to understand rather than respond, I often discover common ground with people I thought I disagreed with completely,” explains Sergeant Lisa Rodriguez. “We might differ on methods, but we both want safer neighborhoods.”
This approach reflects the spiritual anchor that many officers rely on during challenging times—finding purpose beyond the immediate conflicts and remembering the core values that drew them to service.
Badge145 offers several resources for officers wrestling with feelings about prison abolition rhetoric and other politically charged topics:
“The most important thing to remember is that you’re not alone in these feelings,” emphasizes clinical psychologist Dr. James Wilson, who specializes in first responder mental health. “Processing these reactions in healthy ways is essential for maintaining both personal wellbeing and professional effectiveness.”
While political debates around prison systems will continue, officers can navigate these challenging conversations while maintaining their spiritual and mental health. By separating political rhetoric from personal value, engaging in informed dialogue, and utilizing appropriate support resources, law enforcement professionals can continue their essential work with both resilience and integrity.
As we continue to support those who serve our communities, Badge145 remains committed to providing spaces where officers can honestly address the impact of societal debates on their wellbeing. We believe that by addressing these challenges directly, law enforcement professionals can maintain their effectiveness while also contributing meaningfully to important conversations about justice, safety, and community wellbeing.
Remember that regardless of political rhetoric, the daily work of keeping communities safe continues to matter profoundly. In times of divisiveness, returning to your core purpose and values can provide the anchor needed to navigate choppy waters with resilience and dignity.